"Basically all a noodle rod is is a fly rod with a spinning handle" - Anonymous post on a steelhead forum.
The first time I saw one of these outfits was on the Stillwater River during the Fall salmon run. It was at least 10 feet long and fairly soft after the middle of the rod and was loaded with, what looked like, 4X mono with some kind of nymph at the business end. It was, in my opinion, too long for a tiny (and CROWDED) stream like the Stillwater but I could see where the owner of one of these rods could walk right up to the Y Pool and, using the same logic (?) that guides the DFW(?), tie on a PT Nymph and start fishing. Current regs forbid that. One has to use conventional fly fishing gear (it says) to fish there along with tenkara fishers who do not use conventional gear.
Let's muddy the waters a bit more. Tightline angling is, for the most part, fishing with MONO. In some waters mono leaders cannot exceed certain lengths and many of the fly reels there are loaded to the max with mono and far outcast Tenkara guys.
The Flymph
We should make this simple. The determining factor as far as legal fishing goes on C&R waters should be this:
1. Use ANY fishing equipment that you like but NO BAIT. You can use a spinning rod, a bobber and an artificial fly. That's what indicator flyfishers basically do.
2. Single, barbless hooks only
3. This makes the regs simple and enforcable!!
If you think I'm going overboard on this wait until you see my next suggestion.
Ken