"Flyfishing is an act of hope that leads to a net full of fish and a head full of dreams." Fennel Hudson
In my almost two decades of guiding I would come across this type of individual a number of times a year. This is the absolute beginner (nothing wrong with that, I was one!) who gets his gear and heads off to the Swift River or the Deerfield River or the Farmington River, gets totally zeroed while seeing others deftly catch and release trout and then asks himself "what's wrong?
The simple answer is Nothing is wrong!! You just started in at way over your head on three very technical rivers and you should of started on a venue that most closely matches your skill level. What you need to experience more than anything else is the magic of the "tug" and that is best experienced on our smaller streams especially the ones that have been stocked.
"What size fly do I use?" If you are fishing a small brook (picture on the left) that is about two feet deep a size 12 wooley bugger, a size 12 soft hackle or any size 12 hares ear nymph with a bead head will get the job done on a Spring day.How do I fish it? Cast across the stream and swing that fly in the current until it's directly below you and then start a slow retrieve guiding that fly through all likely holding areas as you move slowly downstream. Now, some expert will probably thumb his nose at you for using such a simplistic method but remember that early season streams are full of simplistic fish and you would like to catch some and your method is no worse than indicator fishing.
Always watch other anglers especially the ones catching fish.
Don't go out and buy a big box packed with large goofy looking flies. You know what I'm talking about: big gaudy dries with weird hackles lathered on or monster buggers. Stay with the flies that I mentioned at the beginner of this piece and then go to a good fly shop (UpCountry on the Farmington) and ask for some local advice or read this blog.
As I write on Monday a.m. at 10:30 it is 25 degrees and the wind chill is 12. The Quabbin is overflowing at 276 cfs and the Farmie below the Stillwater is up in the 700's with water only in the mid 30 temperature range. The Millers is rolling along at 1230 and the EB is doing the same at 638.
We have a ways to go!!
Ken